An Englishman's home …

It’s abundantly obvious that Britain’s long property boom is coming to an abrupt and painful halt. Articles such as this from today’s Independent strongly suggest that not only are prices already falling, but there is much worse to come.

It’s perhaps time to start asking the question about what these events tell us about markets and prosperity.

Property price equals wealth?

It is almost axiomatic in large swathes of the media that rising property prices are a good thing, a sign of increasing prosperity. I believe this is nonsense – how can a rapid increase in the price of this most basic of commodities, much faster than people’s pay – possibly be a sign of wealth? If any other essential goes up in price in this way, it’s seen as quite the reverse. Now this is partly because we don’t consume houses – but we do buy and sell them, on something called the property ladder, although the fact that the price of the house we might want to buy in future has gone up means that the increase in wealth is more apparent than real. And we can borrow money against them. But it’s also because there are far more people at any one time who own houses than are seeking to buy one. It’s essentially an illusion of the prosperous.

But there is a social pressure too. Unlike our neighbours in Europe, the British are obsessed with home ownership – it’s part of our obsession with class – and people will take increasingly desperate measures – by which I mean borrow increasingly unsustainably, or even dishonestly, to fulfil the dream of home ownership. And this process is of course self-fulfilling – the price goes up, so the amount that one has to borrow goes up, but so too does the value of the security … until it all goes bad.

Credit crunches and blind stupidity

The recent events – blamed increasingly on what has become known as the credit crunch, the domino-like collapse of world liquidity caused by the collapse in the sub-prime market in the United States – seem to me to illustrate some important facts about the way in which what I firmly believe to be the illusions of market economics are maintained. It should have been obvious that the collapse was going to happen. Increasing lending, desperate borrowing by people who cannot afford to repay in an environment – in the United States in particular – in which real incomes remained static or were even falling – can only lead one way. And add to this a financial system which seems totally dependent on faith and optimism, and the speed and severity of the crash become almost inevitable.

In the circumstances the word “credit” is accurate indeed. What we have is a system in which people who have been sold (not least by themselves) as great experts, manipulators of a fundamentally benevolent system – have shown themselves to be about as understanding of reality as a Roman soothsayer inspecting the innards of a sheep. It’s all puff, all desperate blind faith, with no underpinning whatsoever. In most other areas of life, it would be called sheer abject stupidity – but when one calls oneself a banker and wears a pinstripe suit one seems to be able to get away with stupidity more easily than most. (But not more easily than the legions of journalists, TV programme-makers and pundits who have wittered on for the last few years about housing booms). There is a whole industry – an industry built on an edifice of epic stupidity – that has been building all this up as wealth.

Inflation, inflation, inflation

As any economist knows, there is a simple word for what has happened: inflation. And it’s no less inflation for not being included in the official figures. And we know what inflation does; it creates illusions.

The bursting of the bubble is wholly predictable by anyone with the slightest understanding of the basics of economics. The fact of what has happened over the past few years is that the commentariat has taken leave of its collective senses. It has simply praised the workings of the market, without giving a thought to the consequences, and has shown a pitiful inability to engage with reality.


One thought on “An Englishman's home …

  1. The UK as a whole will consist of hotspots and areas severely hit by economic woes. I believe that UK house prices as a whole will fall again in 2013 . Average house prices of course should be taken with a pinch of salt, there is no such animal. As a visual roadmap, I see price falls rippling out from London suburbs in concentric circles, getting worse as they spread. There will be hots spots of stable economy towns and these along with very desirable properties will be somewhat protected.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s